Pages

Thursday, September 13, 2012

WSJ: The NFL Moves Back into the Dorms

Rachel Neiberding
The Wall Street Journal  writer Kevin Clark looks at the Washington Redskins' movement toward a college-style offense to suit Robert Griffin III.  Naturally, one would think that an NFL franchise might do a similar thing for Denard Robinson, another fleet-footed quarterback seemingly ill suited to play QB in the NFL.  However, Griffin was a much more consistent thrower on the college level, meaning he can adapt to the NFL a little more easily.  I still think that Robinson would struggle at QB in the professional ranks and, like most other people, assume he will have to switch positions in order to make a career of it.

4 comments:

  1. I agree, Magnus...RGIII is a very gifted passer, first and foremost. His athleticism is a nice bonus. He's more Michael Vick minus the felonies.

    Tebow is a good example of when a good athlete who struggles with NFL-level passing gets put in at QB.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "RGIII is a very gifted passer, first and foremost. His athleticism is a nice bonus."

      That's exactly right ... that's the way the formulation should be viewed.

      I think this is why we see (and read) that Urban Meyer is working so hard to make Braxton Miller better at passing. A mobile QB who can occasionally pass is worth FAR less than a good passing QB who is also mobile.

      There is in life an important concept of "good enough" -- and it applies to QBs: a QB needs to be a good passer and with respect to mobility be "good enough" to stay away from pursuit and to get the occasional first down when called upon. I have long maintained that any time a team's QB leads the team in rushing, it's a BAD sign.

      Delete
  2. Can't even concentrate on football...........................wow

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. She's Kate Upton ... but with even *more* curves. "Wow" is right.

      Delete