Quick comments: I think Funchess and Morris need upward nudges. Gallon, too, maybe. Countess is important, but I think he could be moved down. Kalis (whatever his importance) should be in the same neighborhood as Glasgow.
If Gardner goes out, UM is proper f*cked. If Lewan goes down, Schofield could slide over to LT and Braden could move to RT. Not as good, but not a disaster like we will be facing with anyone besides Devin at QB.
I can see a little merit in bumping Morris up, but not much. Bellomy could return from his injury, and Dan Cleary exists. I could see Funchess having a bit of a nudge too, but not Gallon. I have Countess so high because I have big expectations from him this year. Behind him is Taylor, Avery, and then I'm hoping Richardson, or maybe Hollowell, or maybe one of the freshmen will be able to contribute right away. I like having Countess real high on the list - in my eyes he's definitely top 5. I can see the argument to moving Schofield above him, but I wouldn't make it.
I'm going to disagree with your opinion on Kalis. Kalis is not in the same neighborhood as Glasgow. Hoke might say that, and that's coach speak, but he is not in the same neighborhood. I can see dropping Kalis down to 10 and moving the others up, but in my mind I can't find people on the team I feel are more important to our success. Not because Kalis is a superstar... yet... but because our OL experience is pretty weak. This year and next year was always going to be rough in terms of OL depth. I'm really hoping our OL recruits develop. We need either Chris Fox, LTT, or Magnuson to be a serviceable LT next year, with another being a suitable backup.
I agree with Logan88, DG is #1 by a mile. Playing a true freshmen, walk on, or RS sophomore with a major injury at the most important position on the field will have a greater impact on our W/L than bumping people over and filling in with Magnusson, Burzynski, Bryant, etc... That being said I would put Lewan at #2.
Also, I would add Thomas, who has already passed Avery as the first off the bench at nickle. I would drop at least one of the 7 OL on this list. Finally, depending on how the rankings are gauged, I can make the argument that Ryan should plummet, not because I question his talent, but simply based on the fact that he's going to be out for over half the season.
I feel Schofield is a liability at LT. If Lewan goes down, I don't see any quarterback being able to produce effectively. True freshmen quarterbacks aren't always terrible: Henne is a good example. Bellomy could come back from his injury mid season. I definitely thought of putting Gardner at the top, but I feel Lewan might be more important to the team.
I'm hoping the only important game Ryan misses is ND. I thought of that as well, but he's coming back, hopefully, for the majority of the big ten season.
Completely forgot about Dymonte. I'd put him right behind Darboe.
I would be fine dropping Burzinski or Bryant a bit lower if you'd like. This is a pretty rough draft.
I'm putting up my prediction of your countdown to kick off, because it's a slow day at work, and that series should be coming up pretty soon!
ReplyDelete1 Lewan
2 Gardner
3 Countess
4 Q
5 Schofield
6 Ryan
7 Clark
8 Ross
9 Kalis
10 Thomas Gordon
11 Gallon
12 Miller
13 Morgan
14 Taylor
15 Beyer
16 Cam Gordon
17 Braden
18 Cam Gordon
19 Pipkins
20 Braden
21 Green
22 Chesson
23 Toussaint
24 J Wilson
25 Funchess
26 Ojemudia
27 Bryant
28 Wormley
29 Morris
30 Richardson
31 Darboe
32 Gibbons
33 Burzynski
34 Avery
35 Wile
-JC
You need to pick one for Cam Gordon, 16 or 18 ..... or you could average.
DeleteWhen I was making the list in excel, I copy pasted rather than cut paste.There is also another Ben Braden at 17 and 20. I would delete 16 and 17.
DeleteQuick comments: I think Funchess and Morris need upward nudges. Gallon, too, maybe. Countess is important, but I think he could be moved down. Kalis (whatever his importance) should be in the same neighborhood as Glasgow.
DeleteGardner is #1...by a mile.
DeleteIf Gardner goes out, UM is proper f*cked. If Lewan goes down, Schofield could slide over to LT and Braden could move to RT. Not as good, but not a disaster like we will be facing with anyone besides Devin at QB.
I can see a little merit in bumping Morris up, but not much. Bellomy could return from his injury, and Dan Cleary exists. I could see Funchess having a bit of a nudge too, but not Gallon. I have Countess so high because I have big expectations from him this year. Behind him is Taylor, Avery, and then I'm hoping Richardson, or maybe Hollowell, or maybe one of the freshmen will be able to contribute right away. I like having Countess real high on the list - in my eyes he's definitely top 5. I can see the argument to moving Schofield above him, but I wouldn't make it.
DeleteI'm going to disagree with your opinion on Kalis. Kalis is not in the same neighborhood as Glasgow. Hoke might say that, and that's coach speak, but he is not in the same neighborhood. I can see dropping Kalis down to 10 and moving the others up, but in my mind I can't find people on the team I feel are more important to our success. Not because Kalis is a superstar... yet... but because our OL experience is pretty weak. This year and next year was always going to be rough in terms of OL depth. I'm really hoping our OL recruits develop. We need either Chris Fox, LTT, or Magnuson to be a serviceable LT next year, with another being a suitable backup.
-JC
Dan Cleary does exist, but plays for the Red Wings.
DeleteI agree with Logan88, DG is #1 by a mile. Playing a true freshmen, walk on, or RS sophomore with a major injury at the most important position on the field will have a greater impact on our W/L than bumping people over and filling in with Magnusson, Burzynski, Bryant, etc... That being said I would put Lewan at #2.
DeleteAlso, I would add Thomas, who has already passed Avery as the first off the bench at nickle. I would drop at least one of the 7 OL on this list. Finally, depending on how the rankings are gauged, I can make the argument that Ryan should plummet, not because I question his talent, but simply based on the fact that he's going to be out for over half the season.
I feel Schofield is a liability at LT. If Lewan goes down, I don't see any quarterback being able to produce effectively. True freshmen quarterbacks aren't always terrible: Henne is a good example. Bellomy could come back from his injury mid season. I definitely thought of putting Gardner at the top, but I feel Lewan might be more important to the team.
Delete-JC
I'm hoping the only important game Ryan misses is ND. I thought of that as well, but he's coming back, hopefully, for the majority of the big ten season.
DeleteCompletely forgot about Dymonte. I'd put him right behind Darboe.
I would be fine dropping Burzinski or Bryant a bit lower if you'd like. This is a pretty rough draft.
-JC
whatever those tats are... aren't working for her
ReplyDeleteI think she must really like the Rose Bowl.
Deletethat just ruined my lunch
ReplyDeleteWhy do you post these pictures?
ReplyDelete