I'm just going to post a few quick thoughts due to a lack of time:
I thought the run game looked better. This may be short-lived because Oregon didn't have a scout on a non-Jason Beck offense, but the operation was crisper. Harding limited the Rhino appearances and seemed to simplify the run game. That resulted in some running lanes, including a 70-yard touchdown run for Savion Hiter. The offensive line was getting off the ball better in the run game, which is something I'm surprised took so long from Harding's unit. I think the simplification of the run game helps those guys up front be more decisive with their fundamentals. Thinking less leads to playing faster. The result wasn't much better (7 points vs. Oregon instead of 6 points vs. Michigan State), but the Ducks are a tougher opponent and this was a West Coast road game instead of a home game.
The quarterbacks are awful. Michigan's two quarterbacks combined to go 6/20 for 73 yards. I mean, WTF is going on? You have a 5-star talent and the guy who was apparently better than the 5-star talent, and you complete 6 passes in an entire game? It didn't help that leading receiver J.J. Buchanan got knocked out of the game early, but this is ridiculous. Remember the game in 2023 where Michigan couldn't pass protect against Penn State so they just ran the ball 33 times straight to finish out the contest? At least J.J. McCarthy completed 7 passes (out of 8 attempts) in the first half. Bryce Underwood and Savion Hiter went back to their old ways of f***ing up a power read handoff exchange, and center Jake Guarnera just randomly decided to snap the ball when a guy went in jet motion, resulting in a fumble and a loss of 4 yards when the snap bounced into the hands of Hiter.
Smith Snowden isn't built for this. I voiced my concerns over the summer about Snowden after watching his film at Utah. He was a fine Big 12 athlete, but he's "just a guy" in the Big Ten. You can't afford to have this many mental and physical snafus in the Big Ten. He's allowed several big plays where he's not even close to making the right play, including allowing a deep touchdown in this game and losing his footing against Rutgers and allowing an 80-yard touchdown. Jyaire Hill has also allowed a few big plays this year, but some of them have been perfectly thrown balls with really good coverage. (I'll admit that the touchdown scored against Hill was a bad play where he bit too aggressively on an out-and-up, but otherwise, he had good coverage yesterday.) That being said, Michigan was supposed to have a deep defensive back room this fall with Shamari Earls, Jo'ziah Edmond, Jordan Young, Jacob Oden, Kainoa Winston, etc., and nobody has developed behind the starters. That's probably because Michigan wasn't able to blow out some of its early opponents like Western Michigan, so the backups don't get any live game reps to build for the future. Quick, tell me who would be the starters in the defensive backfield for 2027 after Hill, Snowden, Zeke Berry, Rod Moore, and Chris Bracy are gone . . .
Overall, the offense sucks. Michigan has been held to 7 points or fewer in the three of the last four games, and the one exception was against 2-8 Rutgers. Bryson Kuzdzal fumbled yet again, and so did Tommy Carr, because they don't have good ball security habits. At no point this season has Michigan's offense been fun to watch. It's a non-functional offense that reflects the lack of attention to detail of the guys running the show (or formerly running the show).

I've said it before: the 2026 Michigan football campaign is going to get written up as a case study in how *not* to run a football program. The descent into our current state has been stunning, and with a number of factors contributing to the fall. As this is studied, it will be found that signs were there and dismissed or ignored; and with each step downward more signs appeared, and were dismissed or ignored. The issues go beyond scheme or person.
ReplyDelete“ Quick, tell me who would be the starters in the defensive backfield for 2027 after Hill, Snowden, Zeke Berry, Rod Moore, and Chris Bracy are gone . . . “
ReplyDeletePORTAL
Agree on Snowden; just plain awful. But the entire D looked bad. Almost no pressure against a bad OL, the same issue with missed tackles, and star Receivers left running all alone (Zeke made a few plays)
Holy cow on Bryce. Most of us expected Tommy to be nowhere near ready, but Bryce is just a turnover waiting to happen, on every play. Only looks one way, throws into coverage … unless it’s 4th Down, then he launches it OOB. Terrible
I wonder if the dedicated QB coach at Michigan put too much in Bryce's head about footwork, stance, mechanics, coverages, etc., etc., and the guy is just over-thinking everything at this point. When he looks downfield, his mind is just clogged with all the things, and he slows down a bit to compensate, and there lies his problems.
DeleteThe offense is atrocious but I agree with Thunder that there was some silver linings.
ReplyDelete1. A new gameplan with spread personnel -- rely less on Rhino and TEs and more on WRs. It wasn't Beck -- but Beck is gone. Unfortunately losing Buchanan really undermined this.
2. Rotating QBs. I know Whittingham doesn't WANT to do this but we're grasping at straws here. Try to ride the hot hand. Neither QB is good but they bring different strengths and weaknesses.
As for why the offense is bad, there are a lot of reasons even without getting into coaching and scheme.
1. The QBs are barely 19 years old. I don't care how many stars they had or didn't have. I don't care how much you run them instead of throwing. I don't care how old they were when they started kindergaarten (i.e., who is a SO vs FR). I don't care if they end up being NFL QBs or not. These guys are too young to be starting at Michigan. Period. This should have been obvious last year.
2. The OL is a shell. We had a converted DT who spent all year at Rhino being thrown in to start at OG. We have a true freshman at RT (Harbaugh/Sherrone fixed this red flag and now it's back). Guarnera is playing hurt. Gach has no business playing TE/Rhino/OT -- he should be at OG. The supposed strength of the offense headed into the season is a major problem at this point in the year.
3. The TE and skill position talent is lacking. I know people keep insisting we have a lot of talent but I see Kuzdal out there more than Marshall and Hoffman out there more than .... whichever TE you think has talent. I already talked about the OL above. We have some raw talent (Marsh, Buchanan, Hiter, Moa, Johnson) but they are almost all freshman or sophomores.
4. There are no vets to lean on so the young guys are asked to do way to much. It's poor roster construction to have not went out and added some veteran leadership to the offensive side of the ball.
-IYKYK
1) & 4): young QBs and the lack of vets are reason for not being a championship team, but nobody expected that. Last year Bryce was “good enough” at Nebraska and against Washington & Wisconsin; this year against Iowa & even OU. He was “good enough” to win the 8 or 9 games most predicted, and keep us competitive
DeleteBut he got worse, like so bad that a noodle arm, in over his head TrFR passed him on the depth chart … that’s on the coaches
3) TEs are lacking stars, but there are plenty of offenses that produce far more with much less. Both Hansen and Marshal looked & performed better with Lindsey. They’ve been open, but our QBs don’t see them; this offense ignores the position
There’s more than enough talent - and experience - on Offense to have reached reasonable preseason expectations with non-atrocious coaching. I mean, just look at the Defense, which is actually better than I expected
I will clarify that I agree that most of this is on the coaches. But it can be both -- coaches and personnel. I think people (including myself) looked at the star rankings and assumed it would be better but we all underestimated how the total lack of any senior leaders on offense was a problem. It is an incredibly young offense and in this day and age of portal/NIL that is unacceptable for a team that wants to win the B10.
Delete--------------------------
I mostly agree with your Underwood take.
For Bryce -- I think that we see the same mental errors yet again and some of that is just on Bryce I think. He just continues to not see the field very well and yes that will get better with time (probably) but he seems to be behind a lot of other 19 year olds. And if you don't account for age and just say he's a sophomore, then he's even further behind. He's not going to be NFL ready after next year -- I don't care if Lincoln Riley or whoever you think is the best QB developer in the world is coaching him. He is a long way off.
Something like throwing the ball out of bounds on 4th down yesterday -- I mean it can be taught for sure but like -- does it really need to be? Is Tommy going to do the same thing right now? I kinda doubt it. He will get better with time but I think the assumption that he is a sure-fire 1st round NFL draft pick is out the window. His decision making is real real bad.
It's possible he ascends (again, the kid is barely 19 and there are probably some 2027 freshman who will be older than him), but other than size and arm strength the talent is NOT obviously 1st round material. Not even close.
---------------------------
On TE -- I've been talking about this for 2 years but the dropoff from Harbaugh has been severe. Marshall is not an NFL player. Tonielli does not belong in the B10. Maaaaybe Hansen will get there. Right now none of them is as good of a player as Hoffman because Hoffman is a better blocker. But Hoffman is...not a good TE. But he's the best we have it seems. I suspect in the long run it will be Bonner, who is basically just a WR now but has potential to develop.
The TE position is the weakest position of the entire roster (with the possible exception of kicker). Fortunately TE is not a big impact position - but when you base your offense out of heavy 12 personnel...it kinda is.
I don't think the experience is there to be good. I don't even think it's close. When you have no 5th or 6th year guys and your only seniors are Efobi, Norton, and Link... oof.
Meanwhile the defense is loaded with seniors and grads and even a couple guys from the class of 21. Right now our fan base is making this all about the coaches but you can compare the offense and defense experience and it's night and day.
Jay Hill has a much easier job to do. But yes -- we could easily be 9-3 if Jason Beck did a competent coaching job or (say) Chip Kelly was hired instead.
-IYKYK
"we could easily be 9-3 if Jason Beck did a competent coaching job"
DeleteI am *really* interested in reading a thoughtful, thorough evaluation of what Jason Beck did and did not do, and why his tenure was so disastrous. By that I mean something deeper than "the Rhino sucks!" This offense, and the steady erosion of it over the season, is historic in how impotent and futile it was.
Now, problems like this almost always have multiple factors involved, so it's not *just* Beck being "incompetent;" it's not *just* the use of the sixth OL; it's not *just* the east/west run orientation; it's not *just* Underwood or Carr. Some combination, perhaps, along with other factors ... all contributed to what we saw.
An interesting "what if" article, if Thunder has the time, would be to rewind time and replay the spring and fall camps, and the season, knowing what you know now. Given the players that you have, and anticipating some of the OL injuries that were coming, what should have been installed in spring and fall, and what adjustments over the season should have been made? All with 20/20 hindsight.
Most of it is Beck's fault but other factors made it an uphill battle:
Deletefreshman QBs
lack of veteran leadership,
youth/inexperience (across all position groups),
injuries (especially on OL),
transition costs (year 1),
using the wrong players at Rhino (OG instead of OT),
lack of talent (at TE especially).
-IYKYK
Regarding DBs:
ReplyDeleteBerry ('22) and Moore ('21) do not have eligibility left.
I think Earls steps in for Berry and Curtis steps in for Moore.
Bracy, Hill, and Snowden are all class of 2023 high school, therefore they all have eligibility left.
Will they come back? I dunno. But I also don't know if Hiter, Buchanan, Guarnera or anyone else on the roster is coming back either. So I don't see much difference in DB room than any other.
-------------------
The new rules for 5th year eligibility are so great. They align with reality and the way Michigan classified their players, even before red-shirts stopped existing. Harbaugh (correctly IMO) saw red-shirts as an option for some people to explore in their 5th season and essentially not worth mentioning until that decision point. Now they are gone and the world has clarity.
IYKYK
Just watched the Balas and Skene show ... I like Doug Skene and the offensive line insights he brings. He said that the OL is still playing too high, but that Manuel Beigel at left guard seemed to be better at that, playing low and moving people.
ReplyDeleteThe other thing he said -- and he's said this before -- is that the OL just does not play with "violence." By that he means intensity and passion, and being physical to the point where the defender's will to play hard takes a hit. He doesn't see the OL doing that; their body language suggests passivity. I wonder where the responsibility for that primarily falls: (a) the OL coach, (b) players on the OL with seniority and leadership; or (c) the players themselves? I'm guessing what's missing with Michigan mostly is (b).
Arguably our best players on offense headed into the year were Sprague and Guarnera and Jordan Marshall -- none of them have been healthy and none of them are THAT veteran.
DeleteBut things looked bad in the spring, summer, and against WMU too.
Harding like Whittingham has been around Utah a very long time so perhaps something about the culture they had there doesn't 'travel'.
-IYKYK
To the Utah culture issue ... to that I would appear to someone who has watched Utah play, and can assess whether the Utah OL -- presumably pretty good, given their record -- plays with the kind of physicality Skene talks about.
Delete"Appeal" ... not "appear"
DeletePerhaps.... We underrated Moore as an OL Coach. Under Moore, Michigan's OL overall play has been better than the "sum of the parts". We rarely had day 1/2 draft picks and yet our OL play has been one of the better ones in the nation. As such, we think the talent level is higher than it really is. Given a weak QB room, the offense fall apart.
ReplyDelete