Thursday, January 23, 2014

Mailbag: How important is each position coach?

Doug Nussmer works with A.J. McCarron at Alabama

Hello, 
Thank you for the great content on your site. I was thinking recently about position coaches, especially with the happenings at Michigan regarding our new OC/QB coach and speculation about the OL coach and how long Fred Jackson may stay on. There's always a grass is greener attitude among fanbases, and Michigan is no exception. Your honesty is probably the least susceptible to this way of thinking, which is refreshing. In this regard, I was thinking it might be a good piece for your blog to discuss the relative importance of each position coach. For instance, on average which is better to have for developing players--a good RB coach or a good OL coach? Is the RB position naturally more about athleticism and instinct, and so only so much can be taught? Is it the opposite? A rank-order list of all position coaches (+ coordinators maybe?) with explanations would be interesting. 
This might help frame the discussion about hiring/firing coaches, helping to give a sense of the net gain/loss of a particular staff member. I would assume this would be based mostly on your experience in coaching, and thus subjective, but I still think it would be a valuable piece. Just my 2 cents, keep up the good work! 
Thanks, Matt
 First of all, thanks for the compliments, and thanks for reading. I wish I could you a more definitive answer, but unfortunately, your question dips its toes into a bit of a gray area. As with any work place or administrative team, I think it's good to mix and match personalities and strengths. For example, a bunch of screamers and drill sergeants might not get the best out of the guys who take to more positive feedback. Having a group of 10 "players coaches" leaves room for the guys on the team to take advantage of the men who are their leaders. By the same token, some guys who are brilliant tacticians might not be great teachers. Personally, I work with one guy who's inexperienced and doesn't understand a whole lot about football concepts, but he's a motivator who gets his players excited and competitive. Obviously, almost every guy who coaches at the FBS level is going to have a good grasp of football, although they're clearly not all geniuses. You also have to be concerned about their ability to recruit, their ability to set a good example, etc. So there's a lot that goes into coaching besides X's and O's.

As for your specific question about whether a good developer of talent is more necessary at offensive line or running back, I think the offensive line coach is clearly more important. Not only is he responsible for five guys up front (and the backups), but a poor offensive line can submarine an offense and consequently a team. There are some finer points of teaching running backs that a lot of people don't realize, but a running back can get by on a fair number of plays with sheer talent. That's why freshman running backs step in frequently and have success. For example, a running back on an outside zone play has some minor footwork assignments and is told to aim two yards outside the tight end or tackle; after that it's all about eluding the guys in the opposite colored jersey. Meanwhile, his offensive linemen have the same footwork assignments, but they have pre-snap reads, angles, hand placements, combo blocks, etc. throughout the outside zone play. Aside from the quarterback position, I believe offensive line is the toughest position to coach and learn.

I'll take a stab at ranking the importance of each coach, although I'm going to operate by ranking the coordinators as separate entities from position coaches:

  1. Head coach: Everything comes downhill, good or bad. He's the one who's the face of the program and sets the tone for his coaches and players. This is probably obvious.
  2. Defensive coordinator: A shoddy defense can really take the wind out of any team's sails. Although we've seen each side let down the other in recent years (Rodriguez's defense let down the offense, Borges's offense let down the defense), I think it's demoralizing for the team and the fans in the stadium when your defenders can't get off the field. If your defense gets the job done, a big play or two might help win a game even when the offense is stumbling.
  3. Offensive coordinator: The biggest thing for an offensive coordinator, in my opinion, is to utilize his personnel properly. In Michigan's case, I don't think Al Borges got the best out of Denard Robinson or Devin Gardner, even though the latter set some passing and total offense records. I also don't think Borges's offense was coherent enough to fit Michigan's offensive line. Teams can be successful with simplified offenses, as long as they know how to execute against any front, coverage, blitz, etc.
  4. Quarterback coach: Quarterback is the most important position on the field. Therefore, the guy needs the best tutelage he can possibly receive. Turnovers, incompletions, miscommunication, etc. can all undermine an offense's goal and a team's confidence. Conversely, good quarterback play can elevate and inspire a team.
  5. Offensive line coach: As mentioned above, I believe the offensive line is the second-most difficult position group to coach. Along with having to coach five positions, each player has his own unique strengths, weaknesses, footwork, stance, reads, etc. Even if you have great skill players, you can't win if you can't block up front, because the ball can't get distribute properly.
  6. Linebacker coach: This is a very difficult choice here between the linebackers and defensive linemen, but linebacker is a very technical position, and one false step or bad read can be the difference between no gain or a huge gain. Linebackers also have the somewhat unique responsibility of being involved in the run and the pass. One of the linebackers (usually the MIKE) is typically the captain or field general of the defense, and he has to make sure that all the guys in the front seven are on the same page.
  7. Defensive line coach: Going along with what I said about the defensive coordinator, a poor defense can spell disaster for the team. I don't think you have to have a ton of playmakers on the defensive line, but you have to have guys who can do their job adequately so the linebackers and defensive backs can do their own thing without having to cover up for the line's deficiencies. Much like the offensive line, you can win or lose an individual battle with a slightly different hand placement, stepping two inches shorter or farther, stepping at a 45' angle instead of a 90' angle, etc.
  8. Defensive back coach: Some guys in the secondary can get by on pure athleticism, but a lot of guys have to understand route combinations, splits, formations, etc. I think technique with cornerbacks can be pretty easy to teach because those guys are so coordinated and fluid in the first place, but the mental aspect can give those guys the edge they need to make a difference between a short completion and a pass breakup, a pass breakup and a pick, etc.
  9. Running back coach: While the running back position seems easy to play, there are a lot of things that good running backs do to help out a quarterback and an offense. Awareness of the blitz, knowing how the linebackers are going to flow, etc. can help in the passing game. 
  10. Wide receiver coach: The wide receiver position is so much about athleticism that I don't think they need a lot of deep thought from a coach. There are lots of little techniques that can be taught (stance, release, body positioning, etc.), but much like cornerbacks, they're typically smooth and coordinated enough to pick up on those things easily. I also think drills and such are easier to watch and correct in one-on-one or skelly situations during practice, whereas on the offensive line, the whole unit needs to be cohesive.
  11. Tight end coach: I think tight end is probably the easiest position to play or coach at a high level, provided you have the size, athleticism, strength, speed, etc. to do so. Just due to their alignment on the field, they either block down or arc release in the run game or they run pretty simple routes in the passing game (hitch, drag, seam, etc.). There are some finer nuances, like in the zone run game or if they split out wide, but generally, there are a finite number of techniques and a small number of guys to coach.
I hope this helps answer your questions. I've never really thought about the topic before, so it's a fresh idea to me, too.

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

Detroit News: Drake Harris, Damon Webb lead Blue Chip recruits

The Detroit News released their Blue Chip list for the class of 2014, and there are several Michigan commits and targets.

Hit the jump for a brunette.

Damien Harris, ex-Wolverine

Berea (KY) Madison Southern running back Damien Harris officially decommitted from Michigan yesterday, which is the second huge decommitment from Michigan's 2015 class, following Tarpon Springs (FL) East Lake wide receiver George Campbell. He originally committed to the Wolverines last August after being offered in the summer of 2012 when he camped in Ann Arbor. In fact, he was the first player to be offered by Michigan in the 2015 class. While no definitive reason has been stated for rescinding his pledge, his family was apparently fond of former offensive coordinator Al Borges; with Borges out the door and Michigan's 15-11 record over the past two seasons, it's somewhat understandable that the 247 Composite #2 running back would have second thoughts. However, it's still disappointing for a Michigan fan base who expected that Harris's love for his childhood favorite would carry him through to National Signing Day in February 2015.

New offensive coordinator Doug Nussmeier and running backs coach Fred Jackson visited Harris in his hometown recently, and obviously, Harris wasn't 100% comfortable with the situation. His mother has told recruiting outlets that the Wolverines are still #1 on Harris's list, but the vast majority of kids who decommit end up choosing another school.

Michigan has a few options at this point. They immediately responded by offering Princeton (NJ) Princeton 3-star running back Johnny Frasier, who holds a middling offer list. Detroit (MI) Cass Tech runner Mike Weber has had an offer for a while, but he has stated that Michigan wasn't recruiting him very hard, so it might be hard to get back in the race with him after teams like Michigan State and Tennessee have worked on him. Orlando (FL) Timber Creek's Jacques Patrick has a cousin who coaches in Detroit, and Plano (TX) West's Soso Jamabo holds an offer as well, but both of those players seem like longshots.

Despite a couple mediocre seasons, Michigan still has the brand name and the television presence to pull kids in from around the country. Nussmeier has some different connections and some different philosophies, so it will be interesting to see which players get offered next. Two names I plan to keep an eye on are Hubbard (OH) Hubbard's Larry Scott and East St. Louis (IL) East St. Louis running back Natereace Strong, a teammate of linebacker Kyron Watson, a Kansas commit who was offered in the 2014 class.

For other news on ex-Wolverines, you can check out the Ex-Wolverine Encyclopedia.

Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Final Rivals 250 for 2014 released

Drake Harris is the #115 player in the country, according to Rivals
Rivals released their final list of top 250 players today. They released the top 100 yesterday. Here's what it looked like in December. Movement for Michigan commits:

- Drake Harris drops from #106 to #115
- Michael Ferns drops from #202 to #211
- Bryan Mone dropped from #185 to being off the list

The rest of Michigan's offerees:

103. Bryson Allen-Williams - LB - Georgia (South Carolina)
113. K.C. McDermott - OT - Florida (Miami)
115. Drake Harris - WR - Michigan (Michigan)
120. Daniel Helm - TE - Illinois (Tennessee)
121. Demarre Kitt - WR - Georgia (Clemson)
126. Adarius Pickett - CB - California (UCLA)
133. Kalen Ballage - ATH - Colorado (Arizona State)
134. Marshon Lattimore - ATH - Ohio (Ohio State)
135. Montae Nicholson - S - Pennsylvania (Michigan State)
137. Andy Bauer - OT - Missouri (Missouri)
138. Otaro Alaka - LB - Texas (Texas)
151. Jacory Washington - TE - Louisiana (LSU)
162. Bentley Spain - OT - North Carolina (North Carolina)
167. Dravon Henry - ATH - Pennsylvania (West Virginia)
176. Mark Andrews - WR - Arizona (Oklahoma)
186. Nick Watkins - CB - Texas (Notre Dame)
203. Sam Mustipher - OG - Maryland (Notre Dame)
208. Wesley Green - CB - Georgia
211. Michael Ferns - LB - Ohio (Michigan)
220. Roderick Johnson - OT - Missouri
224. Corey Holmes - WR - Florida (Notre Dame)
226. Melvin Keihn - LB - Maryland (Virginia Tech)
230. D'Andre Payne - CB - Washington, DC (Tennessee)
233. Jay Hayes - DT - New York (Notre Dame)
234. Parrker Westphal - CB - Illinois (Northwestern)
237. Dexter Wideman - DT - South Carolina (South Carolina)
246. K.J. Williams - WR - Pennsylvania (Syracuse)
248. Saeed Blacknall - WR - New Jersey (Rutgers)

Video: The Journey - Nik Stauskas

Final Rivals 100 for 2014 released

Paramus (NJ) Catholic cornerback Jabrill Peppers is Rivals' #3 player nationally
Rivals released their top 100 players on Monday. Here's what it looked like back in December. Movement for Michigan commits:

- Jabrill Peppers dropped from #2 to #3
- Mason Cole jumped from #129 to #92

5-stars:
1. Da'Shawn Hand - DE - Virginia (Alabama)
2. Myles Garrett - DE - Texas (Texas A&M)
3. Jabrill Peppers - CB - New Jersey (Michigan)
4. Leonard Fournette - RB - Louisiana (LSU)
5. Quin Blanding - S - Virginia (Virginia)
6. Adoree' Jackson - CB - California
8. Joe Mixon - RB - California (Oklahoma)
10. Jalen Tabor - CB - Washington, DC (Florida)
15. Malachi Dupre - WR - Louisiana
16. Bo Scarbrough - ATH - Alabama (Alabama)
17. Cameron Robinson - OT - Louisiana (Alabama)
20. Damian Prince - OT - Maryland
24. John Smith - S - California
26. Malik McDowell - DE - Michigan
27. Josh Malone - WR - Tennessee (Tennessee)
30. Elijah Hood - RB - North Carolina (North Carolina)
32. Andrew Brown - DT - Virginia (Virginia)
33. Jalen Hurd - RB - Tennessee (Tennessee)

4-stars:
36. Lorenzo Carter - DE - Georgia
37. Solomon Thomas - DE - Texas
38. Jamal Adams - S - Texas (LSU)
40. Damon Webb - CB - Michigan (Ohio State)
44. Jeff Jones - RB - Minnesota (Minnesota)
45. Demetrius Knox - OG - Texas (Ohio State)
50. Braden Smith - OG - Kansas
51. Erick Smith - S - Ohio (Ohio State)
53. Steven Parker - S - Oklahoma
57. Edward Paris - S - Texas (LSU)
63. Dante Booker - LB - Ohio (Ohio State)
68. Artavis Scott - WR - Florida (Clemson)
70. Jackson Barton - OT - Utah (Utah)
72. Nyles Morgan - LB - Illinois (Notre Dame)
74. Casey Tucker - OT - Arizona
77. Christian McCaffrey - RB - Colorado (Stanford)
79. Jeb Blazevich - TE - North Carolina (Georgia)
89. Jalen Brown - WR - Arizona (Oregon)
92. Mason Cole - OG - Florida (Michigan)
94. Jamarco Jones - OG - Illinois (Notre Dame)
95. Kenny Young - LB - Louisiana
98. Alex Bars - OT - Tennessee (Notre Dame)

Monday, January 20, 2014

Detroit News: Drake Harris learns valuable lessons while missing football

Sam Webb put together an article on Drake Harris, who missed his entire senior year with a hamstring injury.

Hit the jump for a girl in a black bikini. You won't be disappointed.